Bicycle and Gear Reviews

2012 Merida One-Twenty XT-D 26″ review

4 Comments 22 April 2012

The Merida One-Twenty XT official press photo

We had an opportunity to go out and take Merida‘s latest aluminum full suspension mountain bike One-Twenty XT-D out for a four hour muddy and snowy ride and naturally we had to write a review on the topic as well. While there’s been quite a bit of discussion on the new Ninety-Nine carbon range, the non-carbon little brother got renewed as well. The biggest surprise about the new fully is its coloring, being nothing related to the usual green and black and dashing color, but a subtle white with very little bling to scream everyone the brand.

Parts-wise the Merida packs pretty much the same what most similar full suspension bikes do. It shares a lot of similarities with the Canyon Nerve XC 9.0 we reviewed earlier and the parts are basically identical in their quality and function (as is with Shimano XT and SRAM X0). They are even priced pretty much the same, so naturally we’ll have to do a more in-depth comparison of these two bikes in a later article. Merida was kind enough to promise us an another go with the fully for that event.

But to the bike. It’s called the XT-D, because it has Shimano’s XT series group set handling the power transfer in the bike and it’s never a bad choice for most people. The scale stops at 13.4 kilograms (29.5 lbs) putting this fully in the average sector and a quite a normal weight for a bike of its type. The manufacturer has never been known for it’s ultralight bikes, but they have managed to slim down the frame down to 2500 grams (without the shock), making it lighter than the previous year’s carbon version, which is quite a feat. Usually Merida is also known for the quality of their bikes, but unfortunately we had to go through a broken valve in the front tire causing our ride to start late. As one could expect we had a spare ready and off we went to winter wonderland.

The weather promised snow and mud. That promise was kept.

The bike comes equipped with a 120mm FOX Float RP2 rear shock in the frame and the fork is a 120mm FOX 32 Float RL shock keeping the going steady. No surprises there, both are quite common workhorses and can be found often pre-installed in bikes like this. The frame is hydroformed aluminum and they say that their new kinematic (their word) design principles are actually designed around the shock, not the other way around. This new way of designing the frame makes the suspension feel bigger than it is and it was very comfortable for even a guy my size.

As usual, the frame felt very sturdy and and although the suspension wasn’t optimized for me, it wasn’t wobbly or feel wrong. The combo swallowed the single tracks, roots and  rocks quite well, but compared to the other bikes in our testing regiment were better than the One-Twenty in control over mushy and wet surfaces. The cockpit felt very alive a few times going from mud to snow slush, especially compared to the 29ers. Feels like this bike is designed for a proper cross-country marathon with its comfy seat and rigid frame.

FRAME One-Twenty Pro-D-Single BC A-Link
SHOCK FOX Float RP2 BSD
FORK FOX 32Float RL 120 taper
BB attached
B-LEVER attached
BRAKES Shimano M596 180
CHAIN KMC X10 10s
CHAINWHEEL Shimano XT 42-32-24
DERA-F Shimano XT
DERA-R Shimano XT-10
FREEWHEEL Shimano CS-HG62-10 11-36
GRIP MERIDA Vise 292
H/BAR MERIDA Pro OS 680 R15
STEM MERIDA Pro OS 6
H/SET BC Pro Neck
HUB-F Shimano M435 cen
HUB-R Shimano M435 cen
PEDAL Shimano M520
RIM MERIDA XCD Lite
SADDLE Prologo Phorma Male
SEAT CLAMP MERIDA Pro QR
POST MERIDA Pro 2 SB15 31.6
SHIFTERS Shimano SL-M780 3
SPOKES Black Stainless
TYRES Schwalbe Racing Ralph 2.25 Performance fold
SIZES 16-18-20-22
TOTAL BIKE WEIGHT (KG) 13.4

Maarten volunteered to be our mechanic to get us going

The main issue with the bike for me was its lack of personality. The Merida Big Nine Carbon 29er we tried was fun and made me happy, but the One Twenty left me lacking for some reason. I like the way it looks, the parts are all right, the weight is acceptable, but for some reason it just didn’t click. Maybe if we would’ve been able to do some proper single tracks on a dry day to really wake the bike up, making sure that the configurations are all optimized for me as a rider. Maybe it was the 29er that left me wanting for more. Maybe I’m just waiting for Merida to make some competition to the 29er carbon full suspension bikes out there like the Santa Cruz Tallboy Carbon 29er or the Specialized Epic Expert Carbon 29er, and that they would be priced for normal people.

Our verdict: ★★★☆☆

The new One-Twenty leaves us lacking, but since you can get one for under 2000 euros, it’s not a poor purchase for a full suspension bike. We’d still go for a 29er first.

Maarten will be making a more in-depth review about the One-Twenty in the weeks to come.

Related Posts:

- who has written 201 posts on Coming thru!.

Markus is a bike commuter gadget freak who is learning the ropes of the bike world, you can find him all around the web - but you can start with his twitter at @banton.

Contact the author

  • Would be nice to give this bike a run in a more technical downhill-ish path. Suspension worked pretty well for me “in the easy woods” so it would be nice so see how it reacts when things get hairy :) It has laid-back angles so should be ok. Bike also climbed well, even better when I was given the hint to turn the pro pedal on *blush*

  • Miha Iluz

    I don’t think it’s fair to give a rank without really test it in a dry day single tracks, from my experience the fast ralph tires are terrible in mud and wet conditions. 

  • Mbr2992

    What a fabulous bike this is! Fast along the flat and on single tracks, and brilliant at climbing! Great spec for the money! Excellent bike all round! A bit harsh to give it just 3 STARS, definately deserves 4/4.5!!!
    They say a poor craftsman blames his tools!!! :)

  • Mbr2992

    What a fabulous bike this is! Fast along the flat and on single tracks, and brilliant at climbing! Great spec for the money! Excellent bike all round! A bit harsh to give it just 3 STARS, definately deserves 4/4.5!!!
    They say a poor craftsman blames his tools!!! :)

@Facebook



Read our manifesto

About Comingthru

Coming Thru (or Coming Through - as that URL was taken) is a daily updated bike magazine - a collection of writings and links that relate to biking in its every form. The idea started from when Maarten met Markus decided to finally start collecting the things we like about bikes and talk about our everyday adventures in dodging moving objects at high speeds.The site is run by a collage of cyclists, most notably by Canadian Johanna MacDonald, Belgian Maarten Patteeuw and Finnish Markus Sandelin.

It all started in the spring of 2010, after a record breaking snowy winter when Markus bought a house 25 kilometers from the office and decided to handle the commuting with a bicycle. It turned out the bike wasn’t up to standards for that kind of stress and the first weeks were more tragicomic than glorious. Thus the idea began to brew to actually document this journey.

© 2018 Coming thru!. Powered by WordPress.

Daily Edition Theme by WooThemes - Premium WordPress Themes